Lessons From Los Alamos
What would you do if one morning you drove into the company parking lot and saw not one, but several cars sporting bumper stickers proclaiming, "Striving for a Work-Free Safe Zone"?
That sticker has been sighted recently in the desolate, high desert country of New Mexico, home to Los Alamos and the Los Alamos National Laboratory. Fifty-nine years ago the A-bomb was born in Los Alamos. This year a series of safety and security snafus have attracted investigators and reporters like a magnet.
In this issue of ISHN's e-newsletter, we look at Los Alamos's summer of discontent for lessons in how to deal with a safety backlash.
Every safety pro deals with anti-safety attitudes. Where do you start to assess the problem? James Reason, a British psychologist and author of "Human Error" offers sound advice: Don't look for one root cause, a single failure that led to the crisis. Look for a series of problems that evolved over time.
So like an archeologist, start digging for details. What's the history behind the safety culture you're investigating?
In the case of Los Alamos, tension crackled from the start. You had the idealism and technical genius of Dr. Robert Oppenheimer and his team of 500 scientists, and the vast political consequences of creating the world's most destructive weapons â€” Little Boy and Fat Man â€” which were understood better by Gen. Leslie Groves, director of the Manhattan Project.
Analyze what you unearth. As Stephen Covey writes in "The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People," try a little empathy. Look at the conflict from the eyes of the workforce and management.
At Los Alamos, there are now 8,500 employees, including some 1,500 Ph.D.s. They're a proud lot, of course, praised as weapons wizards and high priests of the nation's technical supremacy.
"We carry great pride in the scientific work that has been done," said the chairman of the board of regents for the University of California, which has operated the lab for its entire 61-year history.
These scientists and engineers want to be left alone to work their 60- to 80-hour weeks. No distractions. No one peering over their shoulder.
They value a close-knit, campus-like atmosphere to bounce around ideas. Keep it casual and collegial.
Actually, these wizards and priests aren't much different from your workforce when you get down to the basics. They're proud of their skills. Resistant to micro-managing. They want a relaxed work environment.
And many are stressed-out over schedules, deadlines, and conflicting priorities.
"People who are highly stressed are trying to do a good job," reported an auditor from the Defense Nuclear Facilities Safety Board after visiting the Los Alamos lab earlier this year.
Management at Los Alamos isn't that different from yours, either.
The boss is under the gun to produce results. Retired Navy Admiral Pete Nanos was hired as lab director in 2003 to put the house in order. Two former police officers hired by the lab to investigate charges of lost or stolen equipment and credit card theft had been fired. The former cops claimed cover-up, were rehired, and the Los Alamos director resigned.
Nanos wasted no time launching a new safety initiative. "Taking the Next Steps" was rolled out at an all-employee meeting.
According to a Los Alamos public affairs bulletin posted on the Internet, Nanos used the meeting to review serious and near-hit incidents. A fall from a ladder fractured the leg of a subcontractor. Electrical mistakes nearly killed a group of workers. He said 316 laboratory workers were hurt during the past year, with 71 forced to take time off from work.
"We're not up to my standard," he said. "I hope we are not up to your standard."
The new boss said he was sending a message. "Take note. We are setting our standards and people are going to be held to those standards."
WHO PUSHES THE BUTTONS?
In safety you need to understand where management is coming from â€” the pressures and politics driving decisions. What separates cultures like Los Alamos and NASA from most workplaces is the omnipresence of politics.
At Los Alamos, the retired admiral has quite a crowd looking over his shoulder. It includes the University of California Board of Regents, the Department of Energy, the National Nuclear Security Administration, the Senate Armed Services Committee, the House Energy and Commerce Committee, watchdog groups and the national press.
Nanos took many of the steps you'd expect to reshape an organization's culture.
He led senior executives on a retreat. Held all-employee meetings. Revised the code of ethics. Insisted on high standards and accountability. Demanded involvement by top managers. Brought in a consultant to mentor managers on spotting hazards during walk-arounds. Urged workers and managers to spend more time "giving close and critical attention to work conditions and hazard controls."
Then this past July, the boss's new standards â€” and his standing with his "stakeholders" â€” took a couple of direct hits.
A pair of computer Zip discs and two external hard drives containing classified information were reported missing. Days later, a 20-year-old intern suffered serious eye damage after finishing work on a series of experiments using a high-power, pulsed laser. "Everyone was under the impression that the laser was off," said a lab spokesman. It wasn't, and the woman suffered bleeding at the back of her left eye from a lesion 1/50th of inch wide.
Any safety pro could tell you what happened next, especially in a high-risk, highly political workplace like Los Alamos. Anger, accusations, hyperbole. A chain reaction of a different sort rattled through the lab.
The secretary of energy shuts down nearly all classified work at the country's 24 DOE laboratories.
The University of California's vice president for laboratory management likens Los Alamos scientists to school kids. "It's cool to flaunt authority, and you intimidate the other kids trying to do their schoolwork," he tells a reporter.
A Texas congressman declares at a special hearing that a public library has better security over its CDs and DVDs.
"There's something about the Los Alamos culture that we have not yet beaten into submission," the head of the National Nuclear Security Administration tells the hearing.
Headline writers try to help him figure it out, calling Los Alamos's culture "toxic," "closed" and "arrogant." Employees are complacent "cowboys" with "cavalier" attitudes of indifference.
Nanos weighs in himself, suspending 19 workers and claiming employees are in almost "suicidal denial" over problems. He fires off an email to all employees: "This willful flouting of the rules must stop, and I don't care how many people I have to fire to make it stop. If you think the rules are silly, if you think compliance is a joke, please resign now and save me the trouble."
Dozens of lab scientists ask for retirement literature in the next few days, according to one press report.
And then those bumper stickers appear.
Less than month after what one press account hyped as a "spectacular series of security and safety breaches," lab director Nanos said the culture at the lab had turned a corner.
Top officials had met "eyeball to eyeball" with employees. Work was suspended while workers received security, safety and environmental risk training. A science museum operated by the lab, for example, found its evacuation announcement wasn't loud enough and employees needed to be more careful when moving tables and chair for special events, the museum's director told a reporter.
"There's a lot of blame to go around," said the university's VP of lab management. Discipline would be meted out at all levels, promised Nanos.
About 80 percent of the workforce now have a new respect for the importance of safety and security, he told reporters.
"We can work with that," he said.
For how long? Sustainability is always the $64,000 question in safety. At Los Alamos, culture clashes between science and politics have simmered for decades. Now you have backs against the wall everywhere. Employees scolded like children and heavily-pressured managers vowing discipline if not firings. And a widely-held belief that realpolitik rules: the lab's world class science output trumps safety and security "priorities."
If this was your workplace, how confident would you be that the true root causes of safety and security problems had been exposed to work on?
Dave Johnson is the ISHN E-News editor. He can be reached at email@example.com, (610) 666-0261; fax (610) 666-1906.
3E Company â€”Alleviating the Pain of HazMat Information & Compliance ManagementThis weekâ€™s service spotlight:3E Compliance Analysis
You Need an HazMat Compliance Solution But Donâ€™t Know Where To Begin
3E Company will come onsite and perform Compliance Analysis to help identify areas where youâ€™re at risk for non-compliance and make recommendations to help manage your compliance program. 3Eâ€™s Compliance Analysis can assess and make recommendations on issues such as:
- HazMat and HazCom Training
- HazMat Reporting and Fire Code Storage
- MSDS Management
- HazMat Transportation, Spills and Waste
Click here (http://www.3ecompany.com/EmailPromo/promowp.asp?trkcde=OA-CA-P-82604-ISHN) to learn more about 3Eâ€™s Compliance Analysis service and sign up to receive a white paper on "Diagnosing Your HazMat Compliance Program â€“ How Do You Get Started?" Or, call 3E at 800.346.6737; Web site: www.3ecompany.com
EntryRAEEntryRAE is the confined space entry (CSE) monitor for todayâ€™s industrialized environment. A four-gas plus PID makes EntryRAE the only product in the market that can detect common toxic VOCs and hydrocarbons found in fuels, paints, solvents, adhesives, cleaners, pesticides, etc. and provide protection from the unexpected as well as the expected. It provides rugged, reliable, low-cost protection and is used in chemical processing, water & wastewater facilities, refineries, semiconductor production, resin production using urea, nylon production, rail car and rank truck cleaning, sewer entry, and agriculture. Also available is a key new EntryRAE accessory, AutoRAE, an automated bump test and calibration system.
Visit us at www.raesystems.com, email: firstname.lastname@example.org or call toll-free 877-723-2878.
EH&S jobsNexsteps.org is the new EH&S jobs Web site from ASSE, and features up to the minute Safety and Health listings from dozens of recruiters and job search specialists.
Jot down the Web address for yourself, or pass it on to a friend who might be job hunting â€” www.nexsteps.org
Visit Nexsteps today for the best in EH&S job listings from the nation's premiere safety and health organization.
9th Annual Behavioral Safety NOW conferenceThe premier Behavioral Based Safety Event of 2004 will take place in Reno, NV on October 19th through October 21st. You will not want to miss your opportunity to take advantage of the 9th Annual Behavioral Safety NOW conference.
Some of our featured speakers are: Aubrey Daniels - Aubrey Daniels International, Scott Geller - Safety Performance Solutions, Don Little - Liberty Mutual, Rixio Medina - U.S. Chemical Safety Board, Terry McSween - Quality Safety Edge, Jim Spigener - Behavioral Science Technology, just to name a few.
The two-day conference includes keynote presentations, break-out sessions and many case studies relating to Behavioral Based Safety. We also offer a selection of pre-conference workshops.
We are very excited about the quality of our 2004 conference and we hope to see you there! Check out the Behavioral Safety NOW web site for all of the conference details and to register at www.behavioralsafetynow.com.
See you in Reno!!
The Safety CoachÂ® Saysâ€¦ You Can Champion Change!Overview: Very few people understand how individuals and groups come to accept and embrace cultural change in safety. Each of us works through various cycles of change ultimately committing to what is necessary if the change is handled appropriately.
This book will not only help you to understand the four cycles of change but will allow you to engage champions for change who will want to make the evolution toward safety excellence a reality in your organization. This book will make any reader believe that positive change is possible. It also highlights the eight most critical components of safety culture change.
The Safety CoachÂ® Says â€¦ is in story form â€” and its four main characters will engage and entertain you, as well as your future champions of change. Forward by Dave Johnson, Editor, Industrial Safety & Hygiene News. Item #SC008-BK
Orders can be made by visiting: www.davidsarkus.com/estore_book.html.
Single book orders are $19.95 + $5.00 for shipping and handling. For bulk orders please phone: 1-800-240-4601
Books from ASSEYou can order these titles and more from the American Society of Safety Engineers Bookstore on ISHN's Web site. Visit â€” http://www.ishn.com/FILES/HTML/ISHN_ASSE_index/
Among the books you'll find:
- "Refresher Guide for the Safety Fundamentals Exam"
- "The Participation Factor," by Dr. E. Scott Geller
- "Safety Training That Delivers"
- "Building a Better Safety and Health Committee"
- "Safety Management - A Human Approach," and "Techniques of Safety Management - A Systems Approach," both by Dan Petersen.
MARKET RESEARCHISHN offers exclusive market research survey reports including White Papers, Online Training Editorial Study, Web-based Training Study, Salary Study, Hygiene Instrument Study, PPE Study, and more... CLICK HERE http://www.ishn.com/FILES/HTML/ISHN_market_research_index/0,5680,,00.html to learn more about these studies.
DIRECT MAILLook to ISHN's 73,000+ subscribers for your next direct mail campaign. For customized lists, call toll free: 1-800 323-4958; Fax: 1-630-288-8390; E-Mail: email@example.com; Web: www.dm2lists.com
WE NEED YOU!Are you a safety and health pro or a manufacturer or provider of occupational safety and health products or services who enjoys writing?
Shakespeare need not apply, but ISHN is looking for authors to publish short articles (1,000 words) in our monthly issues.
Topics include: safety success stories, close calls and personal experiences, training tips, use of software, engineering controls (machine guards, lockout-tagout), gas detection and air monitoring, confined space safety, personal protective equipment, and OSHA compliance issues.
If any of these topics interest you â€” or if you have other ideas â€” e-mail editor Dave Johnson at firstname.lastname@example.org
We will also consider articles youâ€™ve already written but not submitted to any safety magazine.