MANAGING BEST PRACTICES: Crack down on bogus credentials
Itâ€™s not enough to be just certified, either. "Certified/accredited" is the new mantra. But accredited by whom adds to the confusion. Accrediting agencies for EHS certifications include the Council of Engineering Specialty Boards, the National Skill Standards Board, and the National Commission for Certifying Agencies.
Washington is in a tizzy over bogus credentials. In January 2003, the U.S. General Accounting Office (GAO) released the report GAO-03-269R "Purchases of Degrees from Diploma Mills." The GAOâ€™s investigative report described its "sting" of a diploma mill that allowed the GAO to obtain a BS degree in biology and an MS in medical technology, with honors distinctions, for Senator Susan M. Collins (R-Me.). Senator Collins admits she knows very little about biology or medical technology, but nevertheless was able to obtain the degrees in short order for just $1,515.
To further demonstrate use of bogus degrees among federal employees, the GAO compared the academic credentials of individuals in a government-sponsored resume database with the list of diploma mills at the Oregon State Office of Degree Authorization (ODA) (http://www.osac.state.or.us/oda/unaccredited. html). More than 1,200 resumÃ©s listed degrees from the ODA site.
Itâ€™s always darkest before the dawn. And for EHS credentials, clarity over academic and certifying credentials is coming. National security and world trade are the driving forces.
Assessing security gapsDiploma mills are now seen as a national security threat. Several of the 9/11 terrorists gained entry into the U.S. on student visas originated from diploma mills. New laws that address terrorist threats, such as the Patriot Act, require employers to develop vulnerability assessments (described in last monthâ€™s column). Background checks on employees, such as gaps in employment or suspicious documents â€” degrees from a diploma mill â€” are an essential component of a vulnerability assessment.
The U.S. Office of Personnel Management (OPM) held a seminar this past August for nearly 500 human resource managers and security personnel from government agencies to train them on how to spot bogus academic credentials. John Bear, an authority on diploma mills, illustrated how Internet databases (resumÃ©/job posting sites) can be searched to find people with bogus degrees. At one site, Bear found 5,000 resumÃ©s that listed bogus academic credentials.
Identifying true professionalsCross-border trade in services now accounts for nearly 25 percent of overall world trade. Employers and other organizations need to identify qualified individuals who can deliver professional services across country borders.
To clear up confusion among the many certification programs worldwide (there are more than 1,700 such programs in the U.S. alone), the International Organization of Standardization (ISO) and the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) have launched a new standard, ISO/IEC 17024-2003, "General requirements for bodies operating certification systems of persons." The American National Standards Institute (ANSI) will administer ISO/IEC 17024 in the U.S.
In August 2003, the Board of Certified Safety Professionals (BCSP) announced that the Certified Safety ProfessionalÂ® (CSPÂ®) designation was "among the first five certification bodies in any field to have met the standard within the U.S."
A new benchmarkEmployers and organizations worldwide will likely view certifications meeting ISO/IEC 17024 accreditation as the hallmark for professional competency and demand their use where professional certifications are required.
For example, Walkerton, Ontarioâ€™s municipal water system became contaminated last year and as a result seven people died and more than 2,300 became ill. The provincial government inquiry report included this recommendation: "The Ministry of the Environment should continue to require mandatory certification of persons who perform operational work in water treatment and distribution facilities." The recommendations did not specify what certifications are required, only that the certifications are "based on ISO/IEC 17024."
Organizations that represent the nearly 300 EHS certifications must now step up to the plate and have their certifications accredited by ISO/IEC/ANSI. Only a few will be able to meet the challenge. Those that cannot may still exist, but their value and marketability will be significantly reduced.