Thought Leadership

Why do you make it tougher? Getting the rules right

Being a Safety Advisor (OSHA) is not popular

December 11, 2012
/ Print / Reprints /
/ Text Size+
Bosses hate you because you cost them money.  Workers hate you because you nag them about earplugs and safety glasses.  Everybody hates you because you are forever chasing compliance — chasing company compliance with Acts and Regulations; chasing worker compliance with site rules and practices; chasing, chasing, chasing.  That is why it rankles so much when the compliance required is useless.  If you want to prove that OSH is nothing but a pain in the proverbial, one of the great ways is to chase compliance to a senseless rule. 

Here is an example:


Since the turn of the century most Western Australian mine sites require workboots to be toecap, lace-up, and extend above the ankle.  Slip-on, zip-up, and elastic sided boots are not allowed.  People who have lived in Redwings constantly ask why, and the standard answer (from the company) is that compliant boots provide ankle support thereby reducing the incidence of ankle injuries.  A noble aim, but I have to ask, “Who said these boots would reduce injuries, and where is the evidence?”


I asked the Department of Mines and Petroleum for their data on ankle injuries from 1987 to 2010.  These injuries include sprains, strains, fractures, contusions, swelling and other musculoskeletal problems.  There is an obvious, and major, reduction.  The unanswered question is, “What caused that reduction?”


My answer is that the late 1980s saw the start of mine mechanization.  Airleg, shaft mine technology hadn’t changed much since seven short fellas looked after Snow White.  Tramping round drives and stopes on blasted rock was to invite ankle injury.  Now, most workers sit in a cab (frequently air conditioned) and are most at risk of ankle injury when they climb out.  In any case, this rule about boots arrived in the 2000s.  It cannot be the cause of the big reduction.


There is no point where we can see the effect of boot style restrictions or any other single factor.  The actual figures are 3.43 per 100,000 working hours in 1999-2000 to 1.34 per 100,000 working hours in 2009-2010.  There is still some slight reduction but I relate that to ongoing mechanization.


Why then was this rule brought in?  Quite simply, it sounded like a great idea to someone in the air conditioned office, but nobody bothered to check the facts.  Why would they?  Isn’t it obvious that the rule would reduce injuries?  Garn!  Consequently, pushing the company line only annoys people.


What is obvious, to anyone on the site, is what the OSHA is full of when chasing compliance with this rule.  From now on, when OSHAs want something that really is important, it’s a case of pushing something uphill because everybody already knows what they are full of!  Gimme a break!


The point is this: “If you are going to pontificate site rules from head office, get the rule right!”  If you don’t, you can make your OSHA’s life hell.

You must login or register in order to post a comment.



Image Galleries

Scenes from the World of Safety

Sights, signs & symbols from the National Safety Congress & Expo held in San Diego, CA, September 15-18

11/4/14 2:00 pm EST

Eye Injuries: You rarely see them coming. Practical Solutions for reducing injuries to the eye.

The 3M Eye Injury Reduction webinar will provide an examination of how to help solve eye injuries in the workplace. This issue continues to challenge virtually every industry, and the solution is often times multifaceted. 3M will share some new tools and approaches to help you in solving this issue.

ISHN Magazine


2015 January

Check out ISHN's first issue of 2015, which features articles about hearing protection as well as the State of the EHS Nation 2015 Survey.

Table Of Contents Subscribe


M:\General Shared\__AEC Store Katie Z\AEC Store\Images\ISHN\safetyfourth.jpg
Safety Engineering, 4th Edition

A practical, solutions-driven reference, Safety Engineering, 4th edition, has been completely revised and updated to reflect many of today’s issues in safety.

More Products

For Distributors Only - January 2015



For Distributors Only is ISHN's niche brand standard-sized magazine supplement aimed at an audience of 2,000 U.S. distributors that sell safety products. Circulation only goes to distributors. 



Facebook logo Twitter YouTubeLinkedIn Google + icon

ishn infographics

2012 US workplace deathsCheck out ISHN's new Infographic page! Learn more about worker safety through these interactive images. CLICK HERE to view the page.