Join the club. Everyone is having trouble understanding an economy that supposedly is on the road to recovery, yet keeps destroying jobs. Since March 2001, 2.1 million jobs have been lost in the U.S. New work, meanwhile, can be hard to find, especially for educated employees such as safety and health pros. Of almost two million workers who have been unemployed for at least half a year, one in five is a former executive, manager, or professional, according to a study by the National Employment Law Project.
Specific technical expertise can be an albatross in this economy, limiting job choices. Compounding the challenge, some technical work has become a commodity, courtesy of technological advances that have dumbed down jobs like air sampling. "The art has gone out of industrial hygiene," says one IH.
That chill wind you feel has a name. It is the gale of "creative destruction." Joseph Schumpeter, a Vienna-born, Harvard-educated economist coined the term in the 1930s. He's the rage in Washington these days. Capitalism, said Schumpeter, needs destruction in order to sustain itself. A never-ending cleansing process of sifting out loser companies and industries and reallocating resources to the winners.
Where are the winners?This is how it can work in the safety and health world: An industrial hygienist in his 40s is taking stock after the recent mega-merger between his employer, for whom he's worked most of his adult life, and a competitor. "It's good for shareholders in the long run, lousy for employees," he says. "For every winner, there will be ten losers, some who will lose their jobs, be transferred or retooled.
"I feel a chapter is ending and beginning in my life with the passing of this deal. I'm carefully weighing options and opportunities in this new world."
This IH is going through his own personal process of creative destruction, or professional "mutation," a concept Schumpeter applied to evolving industries. It's messy, confusing, and for those out of work for months and months, painful and cruel. It's a process that could lead to this IH reinventing himself, his niche in the professional marketplace, his personal branding as a specialist. This is what creative destruction forces individuals, companies, entire professions to do.
He's embracing the chaos, as management consultant Tom Peters urges. We don't have much choice. In this "new economic order" there are no safe harbors.
Survival of the savviestCreative destruction's regenerative process produces casualties - always. In the profession's ranks, call it safety and health Darwinism. Just listen to these pros discuss the profession's downsizing:
"A significant number of people that had safety jobs should never have been there in the first place," says consultant Carl Metzgar, CSP. "Since they weren't doing anything in the first place, eliminating their job didn't hurt anything."
"Perhaps those that got laid off were not really passionate about the profession," says Mark Hansen, CSP, immediate past president of the American Society of Safety Engineers. "The ones remaining sometimes work at a faster rate and a higher standard of quality. I've seen achievers perform at three to four times the pace of those just putting in time."
Progress comes at a price. "Companies are finally starting to view safety as a functional area that can be managed just like productivity, quality and cost," says safety engineer A.J. DeRose, CSP. "Companies have pushed safety responsibilities traditionally handled by the safety department out into operations. We've always said safety must be a line responsibility, I just don't think we realized that this would thin out the herd of safety professionals in the process."
Consultant Chip Dawson says he has a number of manufacturing clients where there is no full-time safety pro. Instead, a strong organizational culture values and supports safety.
It's inevitable. No industry, organization, professional society, group of professionals, heck, even a regulatory agency like OSHA, can hide from creative destruction.
Plan for disruptionIf creative destruction is inevitable, you might as well plan for it - both professionally and in terms of managing your company's safety and health program. Why should your career and your program - especially in today's turbulent times - be any different from these examples:
These companies survived, as Richard Foster and Sarah Kaplan point out in their book, "Creative Destruction," but not as superstars. The authors conclude, based on years of research, that even the most admired and best-run companies are unable to earn a return for their investors that outperforms the overall market for more than ten to fifteen years.
The same can be said for probably most safety and health programs. How many will outperform national or industry injury and illness averages for longer than ten to fifteen years? Even DuPont's venerable safety program saw a spike in rates in the early 1990s that company officials attributed to a loss of focus. Many safety programs reach plateaus and coast.
And the same goes for careers. How many careers today will follow an unimpeded, upward projectory for 30 or 40 years? "Maybe we safety professionals have done our job so well that we've worked ourselves out of a job," says Margaret Carroll, CSP, a consultant in New Mexico.
The lesson? Safety and health programs, and careers, should not be constructed simply to survive. That's how programs and careers become outmoded. Accept creative destruction, and design your program and your career to be flexible. Don't get locked into convention. Too many safety programs and careers have cruised along on old attitudes and rules until reality bites and a newly-hired, hassled and harried manager asks: What's your value to the bottom line?
"We must show that safety is an important business function that positively affects profits and losses," says A.J. DeRose. "Now it's all about demonstrating our value to the business."
Cashing in on chaosOK, what's it take to cash in on creative destruction? To "deconstruct, transform, and rebuild" careers and programs, as one management expert says?
The goal: Develop safety and health careers, and programs within organizations, that evolve with changes in the marketplace and meet the market's demand for value.
This requires safety and health pros to be more than recordkeepers and inspectors, vapor or noise samplers, or OSHA police, says consultant Tom Lawrence.
Here are some suggestions: