Whatever Happened To Discipline?
Describing how she brought her company's safety culture out of the dark ages, a safety manager sounded almost apologetic. "Guidelines and goals must be developed and enforced." Pause. "Yes, discipline."
Now there's a word you don't hear much in safety circles these days. Bringing up discipline when everyone else talks of safety visions, values, and "harnessing the enthusiasm of employees" makes you sound like a Theory X (slack workers need close control) Neanderthal.
In this edition of ISHN's e-newsletter, we look at how discipline got a bad name.
DANCING AROUND THE "D" WORD
"It's going to take some discipline to change a bad safety culture," this safety manager explained in a teleconference sponsored by J.J. Keller & Associates. Supervisors, managers and employees all must realize that a "new regime is in, and they mean business."
Her company needed a wake-up call. She was new on the job, and so were her rules and goals. Discipline signaled that this was not another program of the month she was selling. Employees of all rank were written up, even for speeding in the parking lot. She handled it privately, but "getting written up gets around," she said.
Once most of the employees hop on-board, you can move from a negative to positive approach, she said. "People want to do the right thing, they just don't know how," she explained.
Her strategy worked. Open jobs were hard to fill at her company, given its reputation for OSHA inspections and penalties. But word of the turnaround spread, and recently 300 resumes flooded in for 12 production jobs. So why the hesitancy to discuss doling out discipline?
Why do we get policy statements that dance around the "D" word with phrases like "recognize undesired behavior with certain and immediate feedback"?
We get substitute words like "consequences" or "accountability." Even "condemnation." Anything, it seems, but old-fashioned discipline.
Why won't you find discipline on the agenda at this year's American Society of Safety Engineers' World Class Safety Symposium, ASSE's professional development conference, or the upcoming National Safety Congress?
Why does OSHA soften its enforcement role by loading up its mission statement with language about "providing training, outreach, and education; establishing partnerships; and encouraging continual improvement in workplace safety and health"?
Has the workplace gone warm and fuzzy?
Discipline hasn't disappeared. It's just not talked about, at least in public, like a skeleton in the closet.
Safety professionals still agree with OSHA's voluntary guidelines for safety programs issued in 1989, which state that a clearly communicated disciplinary system "is an indispensable piece of a whole approach to safety and health protection."
"We have an aggressive safety culture," said the safety manager of a major Las Vegas casino and resort, eating at a lunch table during ASSE's conference in June.
He oversees the safety of a small city â€” 5,600 "team members," 7.3 million square feet of space, 4,000 rooms, 8,000 guests, 40-50 departments, 10,000-15,000 MSDSs. Thirty percent of employees are Hispanic. Turnover runs eight to ten percent annually. Hazards range from making beds, needlesticks and cooking food to welding, electrical maintenance and slips and falls.
"We had safety awareness, but no focus, no muscle," he said. So he "fired up" the culture with no-nonsense tactics. Safety citations are issued for behaviors that lead to an accident. Get three or four citations and "you have a career decision day," he explained. "Then comes dismissal."
This safety manager also blends discipline with positive reinforcement â€” handing out "gracias" cards when employees are spotted "doing the right thing," he said.
His recordable rate is down to 6.2 cases per 100 full-time employees, below the hotel industry average of 6.7 in 2002. Now he's thinking of applying for OSHA's Voluntary Protection Program.
"What needs to be done?" is the question effective executives always ask, according to management guru Peter Drucker in a recent Havard Business Review article. The Vegas hotel safety manager did just that. His discipline policy follows another of Drucker's rules: Executives owe it to their organization and fellow workers not to tolerate non-performing individuals.
Or in the words of Jim Collins, author of "Good to Great," leaders get the right people on the bus and the wrong people off the bus.
REASONS FOR RELUCTANCE
Experts like Drucker and Collins pull no punches about the need for a disciplined organization. Safety pros achieve success with discipline as an "indispensable" part of their program. So with all the buzz about building safety cultures, why don't we hear honest talk about the confrontations that are often part of the process? It would be an education â€” like assertiveness training.
Companies don't want their necks on the legal chopping block, for one thing. So discipline, like other sensitive human resource issues, is quietly handled behind closed doors.
Image is a factor. Companies don't want to talk about problem employees. And like OSHA, safety pros want to shed the stereotype as the cop on the beat. The role is known to limit budgets â€” and careers.
Plus, "you can't be everywhere, watching everyone," says one pro. So, like OSHA, today's safety pros have expanded their roles to be facilitators and advisors. Discipline is old school.
Also, "accentuate the positive" is the spirit of the times. Psychology professor and safety consultant Dr. E. Scott Geller advocates a kinder, gentler approach to safety. Discipline lectures embarrass injured employees, fuel resentment and make it less likely they'll volunteer for safety assignments, he writes in "Working Safe."
Use the rod sparingly, Dr. Geller advises. Bottom line: "Managers who use negative consequences to motivate compliance do so at their own risk," he writes in a recent article in Professional Safety (co-authored by Sherry Perdue and Anne French).
Research by the Gallup Organization reinforces the benefits of stroking. Based on surveys of more than three-million employees, Gallup contends that truly committed employees:
- Receive weekly praise for doing good work.
- Have someone at work that "truly cares" about them as a person.
- Have someone at work that encourages their development.
- Receive reports on their progress several times a year.
This is Theory Y management. Focus on attitudes and feelings. Motivate employees to be self-directed by building esteem. Give them the chance to self-actualize. Sounds New Age, but it dates back to the Roaring '20s. Today it appeals to executives busy cutting costs, eliminating supervisors, and trying to "empower" employees.
Styles come and go, in safety management and OSHA politics. Enforcement and penalties are out. Empathy and outreach are in. Discipline? It's still meted out. Just call it "delivering unfavorable feedback" and you may not raise an attorney's eyebrow.
BEARING BAD NEWS
Anthony Dell'Isola offered these four keys to delivering discipline in a January, 2001 article in ISHN â€” http://www.ishn.com/ishn/cda/articleinformation/features/bnp__features__item/0,,71362,00+en-uss_01dbc.html
Make it immediate (unless a cooling off period is necessary). Begin a disciplinary process as soon as possible after the violation is noticed. The more quickly the disciplinary procedure follows the offense, the more likely it will be associated with the offense, rather than personal reasons.
Give advance warning. Let all employees know what the rules are and how they are enforced to give them clear warning.
Be consistent. Discipline that's consistent helps employees know what the rules and procedures are. Inconsistent discipline inevitably leads to confusion and uncertainty.
Keep it impersonal. Disciplinary measures are more effective if employees feel that it is their actions and behavior â€” not their personality â€” that is being criticized. Build relationships with your employees so that they believe in your judgment as a team member.
Dave Johnson is the ISHN E-News editor. He can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org, (610) 666-0261; fax (610) 666-1906.
Get J. J. Keller's Safety Answer Book FREE!Wondering which regs apply to your company? Keller's Safety Answer Book can help!
The Safety Answer Book is a quick, easy way to: find answers to basic compliance questions; pinpoint who you need to train; figure out what your employees need to know; assess which safety plans and policies you'll need; and more!
This easy-to-use resource covers over 90 OSHA, EPA, and DOT topics, including:
- Bloodborne Pathogens
- Confined Spaces
- And More!
Don't delay! This is your chance to get vital compliance information ... FREE!
Visit http://www.jjkeller.com/answers today and request your Safety Answer Book!
3E Company â€” Alleviating the Pain of HazMat Information & Compliance ManagementService spotlight: 3E Compliance Calendar & Disclosures
Skyrocketing Regulatory Reporting Costs?
Donâ€™t have time or resources to keep up with regulations? 3Eâ€™s Compliance Calendar & Disclosures service is designed to organize the tracking of disclosures, permits and fees, provide accurate & timely completion of regulatory reports and reduce late fees and fines due to missed deadlines. Reporting requirements include:
- Chemical inventory classifications (NFPA, HMIS, BOCA, EPA)
- Emergency Business Plans and Community Right-to-Know
- Storage and handling of hazmat permits
- Annual/Biannual Waste Notification Reports
- Tracking and processing of permit renewals for underground or aboveground storage tanks
- Preparation of detailed hazmat inventory and occupancy reports
Click here http://www.3ecompany.com/EHS_MSDS_Solutions/ontime_reporting.html to find out how your company can reduce the time, resources and costs related to regulatory reporting. Or, call 3E at 800.346.6737 or click here http://www.3ecompany.com/EmailPromo/promowp.asp?trkcde=OA-CC-P-71504-ISHN to register to receive a report â€“ Compliance â€“ You have to do it, why not do it well?
Protective shades a stylish outdoor solutionGlareX polarized eyewear from AOSafety provides impact protection and blocks reflective glare for outdoor workers. Laborers working in the sun have long fought solar reflections, glare and simple eye fatigue, the problems often exacerbated by use of indoor safety eyewear. The GlareX glasses block off-axis reflective light from all surfaces using invisible, vertically oriented polarizers in the lens.
Featuring an ergonomic and stylish frame, wrap-around styling for excellent coverage, lightweight design for added comfort and low-pressure Spatula temples, outdoor workers should have no problem leaving their shades on all day. Meeting ANSI Z87.1-2003 high impact standards and featuring scratch-resistant coating on dual polycarbonate lenses, the glasses reduce up to 99.9 percent of UV rays.
Visit www.aosafety.com for more information.
GfG Instrumentation is a world leader for gas detectionOffering an extensive range of portable monitors, fixed systems and respiratory air monitors, GfG provides diverse solutions for Toxic, Explosive and Oxygen gas detection. Applications and industries include the automotive, chemical industries, landfills, steel industries, hospitals, mining, public utilities and food processing.
For more information, go to email@example.com or www.gfg-inc.com or call 1-800-959-0329.
9th Annual Behavioral Safety NOW conferenceThe premier Behavioral Based Safety Event of 2004 will take place in Reno, NV on October 19th through October 21st. You will not want to miss your opportunity to take advantage of the 9th Annual Behavioral Safety NOW conference. Register before August 13, 2004 for the early registration discounted rate.
Some of our featured speakers are: Aubrey Daniels - Aubrey Daniels International, Scott Geller - Safety Performance Solutions, Don Little - Liberty Mutual, Rixio Medina - U.S. Chemical Safety Board, Terry McSween - Quality Safety Edge, Jim Spigener - Behavioral Science Technology, just to name a few.
The two-day conference includes keynote presentations, break-out sessions and many case studies relating to Behavioral Based Safety. We also offer a selection of pre-conference workshops.
We are very excited about the quality of our 2004 conference and we hope to see you there! Check out the Behavioral Safety NOW web site for all of the conference details and to register at www.behavioralsafetynow.
See you in Reno!!
Books from ASSEYou can order these titles and more from the American Society of Safety Engineers Bookstore on ISHN's Web site. Visit â€” http://www.ishn.com/FILES/HTML/ISHN_ASSE_index/
Among the books you'll find:
- "Refresher Guide for the Safety Fundamentals Exam"
- "The Participation Factor," by Dr. E. Scott Geller
- "Safety Training That Delivers"
- "Building a Better Safety and Health Committee"
- "Safety Management - A Human Approach," and "Techniques of Safety Management - A Systems Approach," both by Dan Petersen.
MARKET RESEARCHISHN offers exclusive market research survey reports including White Papers, Online Training Editorial Study, Web-based Training Study, Salary Study, Hygiene Instrument Study, PPE Study, and more... CLICK HERE http://www.ishn.com/FILES/HTML/ISHN_market_research_index/0,5680,,00.html to learn more about these studies.
DIRECT MAILLook to ISHN's 73,000+ subscribers for your next direct mail campaign. For customized lists, call toll free: 1-800 323-4958; Fax: 1-630-288-8390; E-Mail: firstname.lastname@example.org; Web: www.dm2lists.com
WE NEED YOU!Are you a safety and health pro or a manufacturer or provider of occupational safety and health products or services who enjoys writing?
Shakespeare need not apply, but ISHN is looking for authors to publish short articles (1,000 words) in our monthly issues.
Topics include: safety success stories, close calls and personal experiences, training tips, use of software, engineering controls (machine guards, lockout-tagout), gas detection and air monitoring, confined space safety, personal protective equipment, and OSHA compliance issues.
If any of these topics interest you â€” or if you have other ideas â€” e-mail editor Dave Johnson at email@example.com
We will also consider articles youâ€™ve already written but not submitted to any safety magazine.